Accuracy Considerations
For read mapping to succeed, at least one primary seed must match exactly (or with a single SNP when edited seeds are used). Shorter seeds are more likely to map successfully to the reference, because they are less likely to overlap variants or sequencing errors, and because more of them fit in each read. So for mapping accuracy, shorter seeds are mainly better.
However, very short seeds can sometimes reduce mapping accuracy. Very short seeds often map to multiple reference positions, and lead the mapper to consider more false mapping locations. Due to imperfect modeling of mutations and errors by Smith-Waterman alignment scoring and other heuristics, occasionally these noise matches may be reported. Run time quality filters such as --Aligner.aln_min_score can control the accuracy issues with very short seeds.